Notes from the workbench

Who to call when the website is down

When something breaks, most people say “the website is down,” and I understand why. From the outside, it looks like one service with one bill. Most of the time it’s six, often from three or four different companies, and knowing which one broke tells you who to call.

I explain this a lot, and the version that sticks best uses the post office.

The registrar is the post office

The registrar is the company you rent your domain (yourbusiness.com) from: GoDaddy, Namecheap, Cloudflare, Squarespace (which took over Google Domains), and dozens of others. The registrar sends the renewal notice every year, and its account is where the domain’s settings live.

Moving a domain to a different registrar is locked down on purpose. It works like a title transfer: the old registrar gives you an authorization code, and the new one won’t take the domain without it. The code is a necessary check, because it’s what stops someone else from moving your domain without you.

Under a Post Office sign, a man hands cash across the counter to a smiling clerk. Behind her is a wall of post office boxes, and one has an open yellow door.

Your domain is your PO box address

Your domain is an address. If you owned a PO box, this would be that address. You pay for it every year, and it stays yours as long as you keep paying. If the renewal lapses, someone else can rent it, and getting it back can be expensive or impossible.

An address is all it is. The domain doesn’t hold your website or your email. It’s the name people type to find them.

The man holds up a small key beside the wall of post office boxes, next to the box with the open yellow door.

Hosting is the house where your website lives

Your website is a set of files, and the host is who you pay to keep those files and serve them up to visitors. In the post office version, the host is the house. In real life, it’s a computer sitting in a server room somewhere (let’s pretend it’s in Ohio). When someone types in your domain name, the internet points at that box on a shelf in Ohio, and the box shows your files to that person.

Hosts run from a few dollars a month to $50 and up, and the price buys different levels of quality: more storage, room for more traffic, and more of the upkeep done for you. Bluehost, SiteGround, WP Engine, and WordPress.com are a few of the names you’ll see. When the site is slow or showing errors, the house is usually where the problem is.

The man stands with his hands on his hips in front of a small house with a red roof. Through the window, a computer on a shelf shows a web page.

The SSL certificate is the lock on the front door

The SSL certificate is what puts the little padlock next to your address in the browser. It proves to visitors that they reached the real house, and it keeps anything they type into a form private on the way there. Most hosts set it up and renew it on their own, so you may never have heard of it.

Certificates expire, though (some every 90 days, some once a year), and a renewal can fail without anyone noticing, especially after a move or a change to the forwarding card. When that happens, the site is still there, but every browser puts up a full-page warning that the connection isn’t private, and most visitors turn around at the door.

A visitor in a yellow beanie stops short in front of the house. The padlock has fallen off the front door and lies broken on the step.

DNS is the forwarding card

The post office needs to know what to do with anything addressed to your box, and DNS is the forwarding card it keeps on file. One line on the card sends visitors to yourbusiness.com to the house. Another line sends email for yourbusiness.com to your mail service.

That’s why a site can move to a new host without changing its address. The domain stays put, and only the card changes. It’s also why one typo on the card can take down a site that has nothing wrong with it.

The card doesn’t always live at the post office, either. Your DNS might be managed at your registrar, at your host, or at a third company like Cloudflare, and finding out which is the first job in most moves.

A postal clerk holds up a blank forwarding card labeled DNS. Dotted lines run from the card to a house labeled website and to a mail truck labeled email.

Email is a separate delivery service

This is where the PO box helps most. Email uses your address, but it doesn’t have to go to the house. A lot of businesses get their mail through Google Workspace or Microsoft 365, while the website lives at a host that never sees a single message.

That separation is the one that surprises people during a move. If someone rebuilds the forwarding card for the new house and leaves off the line for mail, the website comes up fine and the email quietly stops arriving. Before any move, it’s worth writing down where your email goes now.

A mail carrier puts a stack of envelopes into the yellow post office box. Far away, the mailbox at the house sits empty.

Why I keep them apart

Some companies will sell you all six in one place, and that’s convenient right up until you want to leave. What I like to do is keep the registrar separate from the host, because then you’re not tied. If you need to break up with your host, it’s easier to break up with one of them and not both.

Who holds each account matters as much as where it lives. If your developer registered the domain under their own account, the address isn’t in your name, and I wrote about how to get it back in My web guy ghosted me.

All six together

A drawing of me in my orange plaid scarf, pointing down a street. Labels name each stop: the post office is the registrar, the yellow box in its window is the domain, the card the clerk holds is DNS, the mail truck is email, the house is hosting, and the padlock on its door is the SSL certificate.

If you can name the company behind each of these, and you can log into each account yourself, you’ll know who to call the next time someone says the website is down.

Newsletter

Notes, by email.

For small businesses and nonprofits who want a website that works for everyone who visits it: practical notes on accessibility, WordPress care, and the tools I use to keep sites running.

I won’t spam you or sell your email. Unsubscribe any time.

About Bekee Gibson

Owner of gibson•works, llc, in Madison, WI. Over 25 years of HTML, accessibility, and listening before building. I can fix your problem with technology, so you don’t have to worry about it. More about me